Put Your Doubts on the Stand

Should I move to Mexico

Put Your Doubts on the Stand

The Excuses Your Mind Calls Logic, Cross-Examined. If you are asking yourself should I move to Mexico, your mind has already built a case against it: it is not safe, it is poor, I cannot leave my family, I need more research. This page puts each of those reasons on the stand under one rule: the same standard for both places. You will meet the research on how the brain protects the life you already have, the numbers, and the stories of Black Americans who made the move.

Written by Eric Hatch, co-founder of The Black Mérida Experience, in Merida, Yucatán. Numbers checked November 2026.
49% vs 30%of Americans say crime is up nationally, against the share who say it is up where they live (Gallup, October 2025). The fear is bigger the farther it travels.
2.5 vs 24.7homicides per 100,000 people in Merida against Atlanta (TBME Relocation Data Brief, Q1 2026, and Rochester Institute of Technology, 2024 data).
2.6xis how much more likely Black people were than white people to be killed by police in the United States in 2025 (Mapping Police Violence).

Before we start

In about ten seconds, your mind will answer

In about ten seconds, you are going to say one of three things.

You are going to say it sounds nice, but it is not realistic. You are going to say you could never leave your family. Or you are going to say you need to do more research, and then you are going to close this tab and do none.

Notice that. You have not finished the page, and your mind already has an answer.

You will say you are not making excuses, you are being careful. You will say you have a good job, a house and a routine, and that Mexico is dirt roads and cartels. You will say it is not safe, and you will say it with the confidence of someone who has seen the news and never seen the place.

Tonight you will search "should I move to Mexico" and "is Mexico safe" and read only the results that agree with you. Then you will rehearse the conversation with your spouse, play their side of the argument, and lose it before you have said a word out loud.

None of this makes you foolish. It makes you human. But your mind is not neutral, and in this case it is not on your side. It is on the side of the life you already have.

So let's do something your mind has not done yet. Let's put every one of those reasons on the stand and cross-examine them, one at a time, under one rule: the same standard for both places.

Before the witnesses

Should I move to Mexico? How to read this page

Two kinds of evidence appear here, and I label them. The first is research and published numbers. The second is testimony: my own account, and what dozens of Black and Mexican people have told me in conversation.

Studies take years to design, run and publish, so they describe where things were. Lived experience describes where things are. Where the two agree, I say so. Where they differ, I say that too, and I do not pretend either one settles it. Where I expect the numbers to catch up with what we see, I write "we expect," because an expectation is not a finding.

Testimony does not replace research, and research does not replace testimony. A man who says he walked past a police truck and felt nothing has told you something real about one person in one place. It is evidence of that, and only that. Weigh it that way.

The rules of this court

Why the mind argues for staying

Before the first witness, understand the lawyer in your head. Researchers have studied it for decades, and it does not take sides with your future.

  • Status quo bias. In a 1988 paper, William Samuelson and Richard Zeckhauser showed that people disproportionately stick with the current option, even when switching would serve them better. Whatever you already have becomes the default, and leaving it feels like a loss.
  • Cognitive dissonance. Psychologist Leon Festinger described the discomfort of holding two conflicting beliefs, such as "I want a different life" and "I am staying put." The mind resolves it cheaply, by shrinking the wish, not by changing the life.
  • Availability. Amos Tversky and Daniel Kahneman showed in 1973 that people judge how common something is by how easily examples come to mind. Dramatic news is easy to recall, so rare dramatic events feel common.
  • Dread of the unknown. Paul Slovic's risk research found that unfamiliar risks feel far scarier than familiar ones. People fear what they cannot picture and shrug at what they live with every day.

Put together, they produce a predictable result. The place you know feels safe because you know it. The place you have never seen feels dangerous because you have never seen it. Neither feeling is evidence.

That is the rule of this court. We apply the same standard to both places. If you accept a risk at home without a second thought, it gets the same hearing as the risk you fear abroad.

Sources: Samuelson and Zeckhauser, "Status Quo Bias in Decision Making," Journal of Risk and Uncertainty, 1988. Festinger, A Theory of Cognitive Dissonance, 1957. Tversky and Kahneman, "Availability: A Heuristic for Judging Frequency and Probability," Cognitive Psychology, 1973. Slovic, "Perception of Risk," Science, 1987.

Exhibit A

"It is not safe"

Start with the most common reason, and apply your own standard to it. When was the last time you checked the numbers where you live?

Gallup asked Americans in October 2025 whether crime is rising. Nearly half, 49 percent, said it is up nationally. Only 30 percent said it is up in their own area. Fear is largest about places people cannot see, and smaller about the place they actually live. Meanwhile 31 percent said they are afraid to walk alone at night within a mile of their home.

Source: Gallup, fieldwork October 1 to 16, 2025. The same report notes that FBI data showed a 4.5 percent decrease in U.S. crime in 2024.

Same standard

Now the numbers, side by side

Merida is ranked the safest city in Mexico and the second safest in North America (CEOWorld Magazine, 2024). Yucatán is rated Level 1 by the U.S. State Department, the same level as Australia and Japan. Here are homicides per 100,000 people for Merida, the United States as a whole, and two cities many of our readers know well.

Sources: Merida and U.S. national rates from TBME Relocation Data Brief, Q1 2026, citing CDC 2024. Chicago and Atlanta from Rochester Institute of Technology, Center for Public Safety Initiative, Working Paper 2025-02, 2024 data. Bars are drawn to one scale. See Is Merida safe? for the full breakdown.

Here is the cross-examination. You called Mexico unsafe. Under oath, which Mexico? The country has dozens of states and some very different realities, and Merida sits in one of the safest. Your standard for Mexico was a headline. Your standard for home was familiarity. Apply one standard to both and the argument changes.

This is not a claim that any place is risk free. It is a claim that your fear and the evidence are two different witnesses, and until now you have only called one.

The Hive, Ep 06, with Terrence and Ciara. Read the episode page.

"They won't know until they actually come and see for themselves."

Rosetta, on the misconceptions people have about Mexico. Watch at 12:11

Rosetta, The Hive, Episode 11, lightly edited for punctuation.

Exhibit B

"It is poor, and it is dirt roads"

Ask the witness what they have actually seen. For most people, the answer is a resort strip, a cruise port or a news clip. That is a thin file to build a life decision on.

Here is what is not in the file:

  • Mexico City is home to about 21.4 million people in its metro area, one of the largest cities in the Western Hemisphere (2020 census).
  • Mexico has 31 states plus Mexico City, and about 126 million people. Cancun, Cabo and Tijuana are a few points on a very large map.
  • Healthcare in Merida includes private hospitals such as Star Medica, Centro Medico de las Americas and Hospital Faro del Mayab. A doctor visit typically runs $30 to $50 and an MRI $150 to $350 (TBME Relocation Data Brief, Q1 2026).
  • Dental care is so good and so priced that thousands of Americans cross into Los Algodones, a town of about 6,000 people with roughly 600 dentists, and report saving up to 70 percent.
  • Chains and stores Americans know are there. Walmart, Costco, McDonald's, Burger King and KFC are all in Mexico, and Chipotle opened its first Mexico restaurant in July 2026.
  • History runs deep. The Maya built cities, astronomy and mathematics here. Vicente Guerrero, the second president of Mexico, was of African descent, and he abolished slavery in 1829. About 2.6 million Mexicans identify as Afro-Mexican (2020 census).

Now the cross-examination. You called a country with 126 million people poor. Whose standard of poverty was that? The question is not whether Mexico has poverty. It does, as the United States does. The question is whether your picture matches the place you are considering, and whether you ever looked.

Sources: INEGI 2020 census via Mexperience and Wikipedia. TBME Relocation Data Brief, Q1 2026. NBC News, 2017, on Los Algodones dental care (a dated report). BlackPast on Vicente Guerrero. The National Park Service notes that the 1829 decree exempted Texas and that Mexico abolished slavery with no exceptions in 1837. Fox 5 Atlanta on Chipotle. For the longer history, read The Underground Railroad to Mexico.

Exhibit C

The food you stopped questioning

This is where the same standard gets uncomfortable. You can name every reason Mexico's food might be risky. Can you name what is in your own cart?

I shop here the way people here shop. I walk into a market, and the vendor asks which chicken I want. Then, right there, they take it, clean it and hand it over. The produce comes from farmers nearby, a lot of it organic, and nobody makes a big deal of it. Here, the unusual food is the processed food, and it is the one that carries a label. Food has to be bought the same day or the day before, because real food spoils fast. The first time you notice that, it makes you ask why the food at home lasts so long.

I am not the only one saying this. I have had this conversation with dozens of Black and Mexican people, and they describe the same market, the same freshness and the same shift in how they eat.

What the label says here

Warnings you can see

Under Mexico's NOM-051 rule, packaged food high in sugar, saturated fat, trans fat, calories or sodium carries a black warning octagon. It has been enforced since December 2020, and cartoon characters are banned on warned products. In a national survey, 88 percent of parents said they changed what they buy (self-reported).

What the rules say elsewhere

Ingredients other regions restrict

The European Union bans or restricts potassium bromate, BHA, BHT, titanium dioxide and azodicarbonamide, and all have been allowed in U.S. food. The FDA banned Red 3 in January 2025. Mexico bans BHA and BHT, and potassium bromate in bread, according to Mexico News Daily.

Sources: NOM-051 front-of-package labeling study, PubMed Central. The Week, food additives banned in the EU but allowed in the United States, with FDA actions in 2025 and 2026. Mexico News Daily, food safety in the U.S. versus Mexico, which also reports that Mexico has banned 183 highly hazardous pesticides that remain authorized in the U.S. (IPEN, 2018). Mexico has its own food and pesticide problems, and enforcement varies. This section describes what we see and buy, not a claim of perfection.

The cross-examination is simple. If you will not eat at a restaurant with one bad review, why do you accept an entire grocery aisle that other regions restrict? You are not careless. You are used to it. Familiar is not the same as safe.

Exhibit D

The fear you stopped noticing

This is the exhibit I can speak to firsthand, and it is the one few people say out loud. Most Black Americans, outside those who work in policing, share a feeling about the police. It is fear. It was taught to us, and then the news kept it current.

Historians such as Sally Hadden describe Southern slave patrols as a race-focused force that did much of what police do today. The Fugitive Slave Act of 1850 pulled local officials and ordinary citizens into capturing people who had escaped. Then came the fire hoses and billy clubs of the 1950s and 1960s. Then Rodney King in 1991, Tamir Rice in 2014 and George Floyd in 2020. Mapping Police Violence counted 1,314 people killed by police in 2025, a 5 percent drop from the year before, and found that Black people were 2.6 times more likely than white people to be killed.

Psychologists Robert Carter and Alex Pieterse argue that racism can cause stress and traumatic stress reactions that injure the people it targets. Many of us do not need the research. We built a routine around it. When you get pulled over, you put both hands on the steering wheel and keep your movements small. You roll the window down. You turn on the dome light. You do everything you can to keep an officer from fearing for his life, because the world has taught him to see you as dangerous. A friend of mine in Atlanta used to say, hopefully, just stay out of their way.

The argument

Where did the fear come from?

People argue about this in two places, and I want the argument on the page, not buried in a footnote. First, did American policing start with slave patrols? Second, is the fear inherited? In each case I will say what I think and what has been shown, and keep the two apart.

Start with the timeline, because I get asked this. Did police exist before slave patrols? In the loose sense, yes. Colonial towns had watchmen and constables, and Boston created a night watch in 1636. But those men had other jobs, such as fire watch and tax collection. Patrollers had only policing duties. South Carolina organized slave patrols in 1696, and the Carolina colony passed what appears to be the South's first patrol act in 1704. Professional municipal police came later: Boston in 1838, New York in 1845 and Philadelphia in 1855.

How long did patrols last after police forces existed? They were built to control enslaved people, so they lasted as long as slavery did where they were used. That makes the overlap with the first professional departments about 27 years, from 1838 to 1865. That span is my own arithmetic from the dates, not a finding. I could not find a single end date for patrols, and I will not invent one. In cities like Charleston, patrols also did night-watch work, so the line between the two blurred. What the sources agree on is that the control did not stop in 1865. It moved into the Black Codes, Jim Crow and post-Reconstruction violence, and one history of American policing describes Southern police departments growing out of patrol-style organizations after the Civil War.

Here is what I think. Patrols were an early, race-focused form of policing, and the people they targeted knew it. A formerly enslaved person interviewed in the 1930s said patrols were "jes' like policeman, only worser." Here is where the record stops. Historians describe patrols as a transitional police type, and the lineage into some Southern departments is documented. "All American policing began as slave patrols" is a bigger claim, and critics such as Jonah Goldberg argue it is oversimplified while granting part of the underlying point. Northern departments grew out of watch systems. I hold both: the Southern lineage is real, and the sweeping version is contested.

What has been shown

Inherited trauma

Racism can cause stress and traumatic stress reactions in the person who lives it (Carter and Pieterse). A widely cited study of Holocaust survivors and their adult children found biological differences, but it was small, about 54 people, and could not separate biology from growing up around the survivors' stories. Critics say it has been over-interpreted. Whether trauma passes down through biology in humans has not been established.

What I think

The fear was taught

The fear many of us carry came through the warnings our parents gave us, the routines we learned in the car, and the stories told at the table. I think that is inheritance, whether or not it ever travels through biology. And incomplete data is not a no. "Not established" means not established. It does not mean false. This is my belief, and I am telling you it is a belief.

Sources for this argument: Philip Reichel on Southern slave patrols as a transitional police type, via Brewminate. The Saturday Evening Post on patrol origins, duties and the WPA interviews. Brewminate, The History of Policing in the United States, for the 1636, 1838, 1845 and 1855 dates. Jonah Goldberg, The Dispatch, June 2020, whose article was behind a paywall and read only in part. Carter and Pieterse on race-based traumatic stress. Rachel Yehuda's research on survivors' children, as summarized in critical reviews. I did not open the original papers.

My first look

The police in Mexico look more intimidating

I started in Tijuana, then La Paz, Mexico City, Merida and La Ventana. At first glance, the police in Mexico look more frightening than at home. Four or five officers stand in the back of a truck, two ride in front, and all of them are in military gear and helmets, carrying assault rifles. Every instinct says stay away.

Then something happened. I noticed they were not looking at me. If you are outside the tourist zones, they are focused on other things. They are not looking for us, and they never were. In Merida I watched officers wave and say buenos dias. The National Guard posts about a dozen people at a popular federal park, and when you greet them, they greet you back, politely.

When I have been pulled over, the officer walked up without yelling and without asking for my hands. He addressed the issue, I answered, and he let me go. At several checkpoints they saw the language barrier, said carry on and waved me through. Standing close to police at events, I felt nothing. Their glance, when it came, was curiosity. I do not think they come into contact with many Black Americans, and I think they sometimes noticed my hair and kept it moving.

"Here, I will walk to them and take them a Coca-Cola drink and say, buenos dias. No fear. No fear whatsoever. They're regular people."

Eric Hatch, co-founder of The Black Mérida Experience

"I'm not triggered. I don't feel anything. It's like I walk past a cat, and you don't feel any threat when you walk past a cat."

Eric Hatch, after a parade in Merida

The parade

The moment I cried

About a year and a half ago, I was at the end of a large parade with my wife, two of my daughters and my son-in-law, with other family visiting. The parade closed with a display of the police and the military. Long rifles, trucks full of armed personnel, everyone standing and looking as aggressive as they could look. This is how Mexico shows its force.

I watched all of it go by and did not feel triggered. Then I realized what that meant, and a tear rolled out of my eye. I pointed it out to my family. I am not triggered. I do not feel anything. The feeling to evade, to go around, to make sure they did not see me, was gone.

One more difference helped me understand it. In the United States, officers come from everywhere. In Mexico, they are all Mexican, from the same communities as the people they serve. They do not have a history of hating their own people. In Yucatán, that gives the whole thing a balance I did not expect.

Not just me

"Me too, me too, me too"

I work in relocation and community building, so I have this conversation constantly. I have had it hundreds of times with dozens and dozens of Black men. I talk about it on the podcast. Not every man, but nearly all of them, describe the same arc. You are afraid at first. Then you realize no one is thinking about you. Then it keeps getting better. If I had a megaphone and could call every Black man in Merida who has felt this, you would hear dozens say, me too. Our first conversation always sounds rehearsed.

I do not want to make Mexico sound perfect. It is not perfect for everyone, and Mexico has its own police problems, which many Mexicans will tell you. When you come from an environment this toxic, almost anything sounds good. If you have been eating Spam, a bologna sandwich is a delight. It is still not steak. But this is not just anything that will do. This is a great find.

My own reasoning

Calm and free

Here is the standard I use, and it is mine, not a study's. Can you be calm and free where you live?

I do not think most people in the United States can say yes to both, whatever their race. I am not saying nobody can. Some groups have a much better quality of life than others, and no blanket statement about any group holds up.

Here is the part that is hard to see from inside. An environment can be bad enough that nobody in it is calm and free, and the people who have never lived anywhere else have nothing to compare it to. They are not weak or wrong. Researchers who study adaptation have found that people adjust to their circumstances and often drift back toward their baseline, which is how a hard situation starts to feel like normal. Researchers also dispute how far adaptation goes, and some conditions do change well-being for good. In my experience, it takes someone from outside to point at the difference, and then it takes you stepping outside to feel it.

And there is always room to be calmer and freer, even for people who are doing well. That is not a Mexico argument. It is a measuring stick. Use it on any place, including this one.

The testimony in this section is Eric Hatch's firsthand account and his conversations with Black men living in Merida. It describes experiences in Merida and Yucatán, not all of Mexico. Sources for the history and figures: Sally Hadden, as quoted by the History News Network. Mapping Police Violence (Campaign Zero), 2025 report. Carter and Pieterse, "What is Race-Based Traumatic Stress Injury?" Mexico's own surveys show low public satisfaction with police: about 3 in 10 people were satisfied in INEGI's 2025 survey, though Yucatán ranks among the best states on security.

Now the cross-examination. You said you cannot leave because it is not safe. Safe from what, and for whom? If the safest thing you can do is hold the steering wheel at ten and two and keep the dome light on, then ask who your standard of safety was written for. Then ask what it costs your body to live that way every day. There is nothing weak in noticing it. The point is that most of us never learned that it was optional.

Exhibit E

The guilt of slowing down

Here is a reason you will not say out loud. You do not trust that you are allowed to rest.

The numbers are on your side of the confession. A 2015 survey found that 55 percent of U.S. workers did not use all their vacation days, forfeiting about 658 million days that year, and 56 percent said they felt guilty if they were not productive on time off. Nearly a decade later, the pattern showed up again. In an October 2024 survey of 1,387 U.S. employees, Eagle Hill Consulting found that 48 percent did not expect to use all of their vacation by year end. The two surveys measure different things, days left unused in 2015 and days people expect to leave unused in 2024, so treat them as two signals, not one trend line. Research by Christopher Hsee and colleagues in Psychological Science found that people tend to choose busyness over idleness unless they have a justification, and that the people who stayed busy were happier.

That is the lawyer in your head again. It has taught you that rest has to be earned, justified and defended. Then it tells you a slower life would be wasteful, and you call that wisdom.

"I took Zoom off my phone. I said, I'm not doing another Zoom, another conference call, another meeting. I don't want to be in charge of anything."

Rosetta, on her first months in Merida. Watch at 10:45

"You know, I'm retired now, so I'll do what I want."

Rosetta. Watch at 9:39

Sources: the 2015 vacation figures are from a survey reported by NBC News. The 2024 figure is from Eagle Hill Consulting, survey fielded October 4 to 9, 2024, 1,387 U.S. employees. Hsee, Yang and Wang, "Idleness Aversion and the Need for Justifiable Busyness," Psychological Science, via the Association for Psychological Science. Rosetta, The Hive, Episode 11, lightly edited for punctuation. Read Retire in Merida, Mexico for her full story.

Now the cross-examination. You said you cannot slow down. Cannot, or have not been given permission? The people who made this move report the same discovery. Slower is not lazier. It is a different relationship with time, and for many of us it is the first one we have had.

Exhibit F

"What about my family?"

This one is real, and it deserves respect. It also deserves the same cross-examination as the rest.

Psychologists Daniel Gilbert and Timothy Wilson call it affective forecasting. People predict how they will feel after a change, and they get it wrong in a pattern. They overestimate how intense the bad feelings will be and how long they will last, and they underestimate how well they will adapt. The imagined version of the move is almost always worse than the real one.

Then comes the conversation with your spouse, the one you have rehearsed so many times that you already know how it ends. Which means you are arguing with a version of them that you wrote. You have not asked what they actually want.

The family question also hides a second question. Are you protecting your family from the move, or from the discomfort of deciding?

"I felt guilt when I left, and that was hard, and it was heavy, because I left my people."

Angela, on leaving the United States. Watch at 12:44

"My great-grandmother left everything in New Orleans and was part of that great migration. Every day I thank her for the sacrifices she made, because she saw this. This was her dream."

Angela, on why she came. Watch at 23:34

Sources: Wilson and Gilbert, "Affective Forecasting," a research program summarized by The Decision Lab. Angela, The Hive, Episode 10, lightly edited for punctuation. Read the episode page.

The question left open

Should I move to Mexico? Which reason is the real one?

You came here with one question: should I move to Mexico? You have now heard the witnesses. Safety, poverty, food, police, rest and family have each taken the stand, and each has been held to the standard you use everywhere else.

Some of those reasons survived. Moving countries is a real decision, and you may have good reasons to wait. We are not here to talk you out of caution. We are here to ask whether it is caution, or something that has been wearing its clothes.

So here is the one question the cross-examination leaves open. If every one of those reasons were settled tomorrow, what would you say next?

Whatever you say, that is the real one. That is the witness worth talking to.

Free live masterclass

Bring your hardest question. Our team answers it in real time. Join the live masterclass.

Take the quiz

See where you are in the decision, in a few minutes. Take the quiz.

Scouting trip

Test the doubts in person, then decide. Plan a scouting trip.

Questions

Questions we hear

Is it safe to move to Mexico?

It depends on where, because Mexico has dozens of states with very different realities. Merida is ranked the safest city in Mexico and the second safest in North America (CEOWorld Magazine, 2024), and Yucatán is rated Level 1 by the U.S. State Department. Its homicide rate is about 2.5 per 100,000 people, against 6.8 for the United States as a whole. No place is risk free, so check the advisory for the specific state. See how safe Merida is.

Why do I keep finding reasons not to move to Mexico?

Researchers have documented several habits of the mind. Status quo bias makes people stick with what they have, cognitive dissonance shrinks a wish to resolve the discomfort, and the availability heuristic makes dramatic news feel common. None of these is evidence about Mexico. A useful test is to apply the same standard to both places.

Is Mexico all dirt roads and cartels?

No. Mexico City has about 21.4 million people in its metro area, and Mexico has 31 states plus Mexico City and about 126 million people (2020 census). Safety and conditions vary widely from state to state, and resort areas and border cities are a small part of the country.

Are the police in Mexico dangerous for Black Americans?

Black men we know in Merida describe the opposite of what they felt at home. They say the fear fades once they realize officers are not focused on them, and that traffic stops and checkpoints are calm. That is experience in Merida and Yucatán, not a promise for all of Mexico. Mexico has its own police problems, and in INEGI's 2025 survey only about 3 in 10 Mexicans were satisfied with their city police.

Did American policing start with slave patrols?

Partly, and historians disagree about how far. South Carolina organized slave patrols in 1696 and the Carolina colony passed a patrol act in 1704, decades before the first professional municipal police departments in Boston (1838), New York (1845) and Philadelphia (1855). Historians describe patrols as a transitional police type, and one history of American policing traces some Southern departments to patrol-style organizations. The claim that all American policing began as slave patrols is contested, because Northern departments grew out of watch systems.

Is the fear of police inherited?

Racism can cause stress and traumatic stress reactions in the person who lives it. Whether trauma passes down through biology in humans has not been established, and a widely cited study of survivors and their children was small and could not separate biology from family stories. Not established does not mean false. Our view is that the fear is taught, through the warnings, routines and stories families pass on, and we label that as a belief.

Is the food in Mexico healthier?

Many people we know eat fresher food because they shop at local markets and buy it the same day or the day before. Mexico also requires black warning octagons on packaged foods high in sugar, saturated fat, trans fat, calories or sodium, a rule enforced since December 2020. Mexico has its own food and pesticide problems, so look at what you buy, not just where you live.

Will I feel guilty slowing down in Mexico?

Many Americans do. A 2015 survey found 55 percent of U.S. workers left vacation days unused, and an October 2024 survey by Eagle Hill Consulting found 48 percent did not expect to use all of theirs. The two surveys measure different things. Research by Christopher Hsee and colleagues found people tend to choose busyness unless they have a justification. Rosetta, who retired to Merida, describes taking Zoom off her phone and deciding she did not want to be in charge of anything.

How do I talk to my spouse about moving to Mexico?

Ask what they want before you argue with the version of them you imagined. Research on affective forecasting shows people overestimate how bad a change will feel and how long it will last. Many couples find it easier to decide after hearing from people who have done it, which is what our free live masterclass and a scouting trip are for. Join the live masterclass.

Is moving to Mexico running away?

Not for the people we work with. They describe a choice, not an escape. You are not running from something. You are walking toward something.

How do I know if I am ready to move to Mexico?

Take the short quiz to see where you are in the decision, join a free live masterclass with your questions, and consider a scouting trip so you can test your doubts in person before you commit. Take the quiz.

Will this information still be accurate next year?

Parts of it will not be. Crime figures, advisories, prices and rules change. This page was checked in November 2026, so confirm anything important before you act.

Next step

You do not have to decide alone

Start with the free live masterclass. Ask the question your mind keeps arguing with, and hear from people who stood where you are standing.

You are not running from something. You are walking toward something.

Sources

Where the evidence comes from

  1. Gallup, crime perceptions poll, fieldwork October 1 to 16, 2025, for the 49, 30 and 31 percent figures and the FBI 4.5 percent decrease in 2024.
  2. TBME Relocation Data Brief, Q1 2026. Rochester Institute of Technology, Center for Public Safety Initiative, Working Paper 2025-02, 2024 data. CEOWorld Magazine, 2024. U.S. State Department advisory for Yucatán.
  3. Samuelson and Zeckhauser, 1988. Festinger, 1957. Tversky and Kahneman, 1973. Slovic, 1987. Wilson and Gilbert on affective forecasting. Hsee, Yang and Wang on idleness aversion.
  4. Mapping Police Violence (Campaign Zero), 2025 report, for 1,314 killings and the 2.6 times disparity. Sally Hadden on slave patrols, via the History News Network. Carter and Pieterse on race-based traumatic stress.
  5. INEGI 2020 census via Mexperience and Wikipedia, for Mexico City, the number of states and Afro-Mexican population. BlackPast and the National Park Service on Vicente Guerrero and the abolition of slavery.
  6. NOM-051 labeling study, PubMed Central. The Week and Mexico News Daily on additives and pesticides. IPEN, 2018, as reported by Mexico News Daily.
  7. NBC News, 2017, on dental care in Los Algodones. Fox 5 Atlanta on Chipotle in Mexico. NBC News, 2015, on unused vacation days. Eagle Hill Consulting, 2024, on workers who expect to leave vacation unused.
  8. Philip Reichel on slave patrols as a transitional police type, via Brewminate. The Saturday Evening Post on patrol history. Brewminate, The History of Policing in the United States, for early watch and municipal police dates. Jonah Goldberg, The Dispatch, 2020. Brickman and Campbell, 1971, and Brickman, Coates and Janoff-Bulman, 1978, on hedonic adaptation, and Lucas and colleagues, 2003, on its limits, as summarized in Wikipedia's hedonic treadmill entry.
  9. INEGI, 2025, public satisfaction with police, as reported by La Razón.
  10. The Hive podcast, Episodes 06, 10 and 11, for Terrence, Angela and Rosetta, with timestamps linked on YouTube.